For the members of a prison book club at Mississippi’s Wilkinson County Correctional Facility, reading the nonfiction book Framed, about 10 people who were wrongfully convicted of violent crimes, was an unexpected revelation.
“When you get arrested, people don’t know anything about you other than you’re wearing an orange jumpsuit, in handcuffs,” observes the member known as X-Man during a discussion of the book in “Hidden Mirrors,” the club’s podcast. “The public sees you in your prison regalia, they automatically think you’re guilty.”
Although none of the men in the book club claim to have been wrongfully convicted, in X-Man’s view, that kind of prejudice, which is on shocking display in Framed, coauthored by John Grisham and Jim McCloskey in 2024, can mislead witnesses, investigators, prosecutors, juries—even inmates like him.
“I’m in prison for taking someone’s life,” X-Man says, “but if we hear a guy allegedly raped a three-year-old, we say: ‘Throw him away.’ Maybe he didn’t do it, but even us in prison think that way.”
In fact, two men whose stories are told in Framed were convicted of murdering and in once case raping three-year-old girls—and neither did it.
If a convicted murderer can potentially reach the wrong conclusion about another person accused of a crime, it is easy to see how people sitting in judgment can do the same. As the Framed authors note, it is tempting for juries to believe supposed experts who in some cases guide them to reach unjustified, profoundly wrong conclusions. The result is that innocent people go to prison and are sometimes sentenced to death.
Among the common threads running through the book’s harrowing stories is investigators and prosecutors cherrypicking evidence to support a preconceived conclusion while ignoring clues that point in different directions. Juries end up being swayed. Despite the familiar judicial mantra that a person is innocent until proven guilty, the opposite is sometimes the case: guilty until proven innocent, as one of the book’s chapter titles suggests. “Proven” is a legal conclusion. It is not always true.
Authors uncover, amplify truth
Framed presents the personal and societal horrors of wrongful convictions to a broader audience than is typically reached by carceral reporting, and it is eye-opening, as evidenced by the sometimes shocked response of the Wilkinson book club, among a group of such clubs at state prisons sponsored by the Mississippi Humanities Council.
Grisham has authored 50 bestselling books, all but two of which are fiction. Both of his nonfiction books, Framed and the previous The Innocent Man, focus on wrongfully convicted men and women. The Innocent Man was also the basis for a Netflix documentary series by the same name.
Because Grisham’s readers number in the millions, he and McCloskey, a lay minister who founded Centurion Ministries, the first organization in the United States dedicated to exonerating innocent people convicted of crimes, present deeply disturbing evidence of injustice to an audience that might not have previously considered the possibilities, much less be driven to push for change.
In one case the authors highlight, a woman entered a convenience store late at night in a small Missouri town and, seeing no cashier and getting no response when she called out, left. As she drove away, she noticed a group of suspicious looking men exiting the rear of the building. The next day, upon hearing that the store clerk had been murdered, she reported what she had seen to the police, and in an astonishing turn of events, they ignored that and other leads and instead focused on her as a suspect. After a misguided investigation, the woman was tried and convicted of capital murder and sentenced to life without parole for 50 years (only one juror stood between her and the death penalty). She served more than 16 years—all for having simply done her civic duty—before being exonerated. Because the police focused on the woman, the actual killer was never identified nor caught.
It is hard to imagine how such a thing could have happened, yet Framed includes numerous equally stunning examples. A Wilkinson club member who goes by the name Chris2 observes in the podcast (which, full disclosure: I host), “I’m a convict. I’ve been down seven years, got nine to go, and still, the stories in this book seemed unbelievable. I couldn’t believe them.” It is not that he literally does not believe them, he is just astounded that such things could happen.
One bewildering detail highlighted in Framed is that some of these innocent people pleaded guilty to crimes they were accused of yet did not commit. As the authors explain, this sometimes happens because detectives and prosecutors wear down suspects during long, tense, exhausting interrogations, causing them to become disoriented and increasingly desperate. Sometimes suspects are told that the case against them is solid and they’re threatened with the death penalty unless they plead guilty to a lesser crime. Many see no other way out.
This struck a familiar chord with the Wilkinson club members, several of whom say they experienced firsthand the kinds of questionable law enforcement and prosecutorial tactics that led to the wrongful convictions cited in the book. Some of the men personally pleaded guilty to crimes that they say they did not commit to strike more attractive sentencing deals. One says he took a plea bargain for a bogus crime because it meant the difference between a sentence of 20 and 60 years.
Once you open the door to that kind of manipulation of outcomes, it is perhaps unsurprising that the result may be unjust. And as Framed makes clear, the lives of innocent people hang in the balance.
Wrongful convictions and debate over death penalty
In early October, Grisham, who is also a lawyer and a former Mississippi legislator, spoke about wrongful convictions at a 10-year celebration of the founding of the news site Mississippi Today. He told the audience that his research into The Innocent Man caused him to change his mind about the death penalty. He is now against it. The Innocent Man focuses on the conviction and near-execution of a man named Ron Williamson, who sat on Oklahoma’s death row for 11 years for a rape and murder that he did not commit.
After subsequently publishing Framed, Grisham said, he had planned to put nonfiction writing behind him, yet he is now working on another true story about a wrongful conviction in Texas. His enduring focus illustrates that once people are made aware of such injustices, it is hard to look away. It could happen to anyone.
Several of the cases in Framed took place in Mississippi, all involving people wrongfully convicted due to bad forensics investigations and other official errors. They include the cases of Kennedy Brewer and Levon Brooks, who each spent 15 years behind bars for crimes they did not commit, for the rape and murder of three-year-old girls in Noxubee County—separate but nearly identical crimes. Brewer spent seven of his 15 years on death row before DNA testing proved his innocence and implicated the real perpetrator, who then confessed to both crimes, which led to Brooks’s exoneration.
Grisham references the two cases in a chapter about botched autopsies and improper forensics investigations, along with several other Mississippi cases that similarly victimized innocent people, including one who spent 26 years on death row before being exonerated.
Another particularly egregious wrongful Mississippi conviction that recently again made the news involved Curtis Flowers, who was sentenced to death after six trials for the murders of four people at a Winona furniture store. An investigation into questionable prosecutorial tactics by reporters at American Public Media’s “In the Dark” podcast later prompted prosecution witnesses to recant their stories, and in 2019, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Flowers’s conviction and death sentence, finding that prosecutors had unconstitutionally excluded Black prospective jurors. Flowers was then released from prison after having spent nearly 23 years on death row. In 2020, all charges against him were dropped and the following year the state agreed to pay him $500,000 over the course of 10 years in compensation for his wrongful imprisonment. On Flowers’s behalf, a local chapter of the NAACP sued the district attorney who drove the charges against him, but the case was dismissed on procedural grounds. Flowers died on Oct. 7, 2026, of complications from diabetes. He was 56.
In a statement Flowers gave to the press after his exoneration, he said, “Today, I am finally free from the injustice that left me locked in a box for nearly 23 years. I’ve been asked if I ever thought this day would come. I have been blessed with a family that never gave up on me and with them by my side, I knew it would.”
Others are not always so lucky. Among the wrongfully convicted people highlighted in Framed, one man was put to death in Texas before his wrongful conviction could be reversed. He had been the victim of a horrendous tragedy in which his three children were burned alive in a house fire. He was not an arsonist and triple murderer, as prosecutors had successfully argued. Yet he was put to death anyway.
The Death Penalty Information Center reported in 2021 that at least 185 people had been wrongfully convicted, sentenced to death, then exonerated since 1973 across the United States. The majority of the convictions stemmed from misconduct by police, prosecutors or other government officials. The organization lists multiple cases in which people were executed who are now believed (or have been proven) to have been innocent. Six of the 185 cases were in Mississippi. One exoneration was the result of a false confession and one a mistaken witness ID, while four wrongful convictions were attributed to false or misleading forensic evidence, three to perjury or false accusation and five to official misconduct.
As the Death Penalty Information report notes, “The data show that for every 8.3 executions carried out in the United States, a wrongfully condemned death-row prisoner is exonerated. That is an appallingly and unacceptably high rate of error.” The statistic, according to the report, “raises the fundamental question of whether we can trust our state and federal governments to fairly, honestly and reliably carry out capital punishment.”
Minimizing damage from wrongful convictions—and addressing consequences
During their reading of Framed, the Wilkinson book club members hoped to speak with Grisham via a Zoom call about the cases cited in the book, as they have done with other authors, but he did not respond to the request. One of their questions was what recommendations he might have for preventing wrongful convictions. He and McCloskey allude to the root causes in the book but do not directly call for action to mitigate them.
The book club member known as Dollar notes that exonerations in the book sometimes took as long as two decades to come about, and wonders about other cases the authors researched in which the defendant was clearly innocent but was never set free. Beyond that: What can be done to stop this from happening?
An inherent problem is that the judicial process is subject to significant variables from one district or court to another, which makes it difficult to effectively monitor and regulate outcomes. This is evident in the club members’ own sentences, which range from 15 years for murder to two life sentences without parole for an attempted murder. There are also questions about evidence and how it is used, about how to account for variations among judges and juries, and about why errant judicial and law enforcement officials are rarely brought to task, even for making seemingly intentional errors.
Mississippi has made a few strides. HB 681, introduced by state Rep. Cheikh Taylor (D-Starkville) during the 2026 legislative session, removed the statutory limit on damages for individuals who were wrongfully convicted or incarcerated. The legislature had previously enacted laws allowing wrongfully convicted individuals to petition for post-conviction DNA testing and mandating the preservation of biological evidence by law enforcement. Lawmakers also passed a measure enabling compensation for wrongful convictions. One measure that failed cited “the particular and substantial horror of being imprisoned for a crime one did not commit.”
The Innocence Project, on whose board Grisham sits, reported that back in 2009 the exonerations of the two Noxubee County men, Kennedy Brewer and Levon Brooks, who were wrongfully convicted of the murders of the three-year-old girls, prompted the legislature to adopt what the organization described as major criminal justice reforms. In the wake of the men’s exonerations, in which the Innocence Project was instrumental, the Mississippi Legislature passed its DNA and compensation bills.
Despite those laws, criminal justice outcomes remain wildly uneven and still have the potential for the “particular and substantial horror” of innocent people going to prison and potentially to their deaths for crimes they did not commit.
For the men in the Wilkinson book club, that raises new questions about their fellow inmates. Chris2 observes in the podcast, “You got these guys who are locked up, and they tell you they didn’t do it, and you think: ‘You did it.’ But now I think some of those guys who say they didn’t do it—they didn’t do it.’”
Another member, Justin, says, “It makes you look around and ask yourself: Are these people I’m incarcerated with even supposed to be here?”
Image: John Grisham (Getty Images)



